Domașnea: The Microhistory of a Collectivisation

(SMARANDA VULTUR in "22" magazine, no. 876, 19-25 Decem­ber 2006)

A start­ing point

Ac­cord­ing to the of­fi­cial party doc­u­ments, the found­ing of the Domașnea Col­lect­ive Ag­ri­cul­tur­al Farm (GAC) was a new vic­tory won by the Ro­mani­an people led by the Ro­mani­an Work­er­s' Party, "a vic­tory of his­tor­ic sig­ni­fic­ance on the road to com­plet­ing the build­ing of so­cial­ism", as the doc­u­ments of the time put it. In May 1963, only a year after the GAC was foun­ded, the re­ports and minutes of the meet­ings of the Ex­ec­ut­ive Com­mit­tee of the People's Coun­cil speak of in­tense, en­thu­si­ast­ic work to put into prac­tice the great ob­ject­ives set (by the party, of course, through dir­ect­ives). Some of these con­cern the fig­ures of the pro­duc­tion plan, others aims harder to meas­ure, such as "the de­vel­op­ment of so­cial­ist con­scious­ness".

It is no longer a ques­tion, as in the 1950s, of a fierce struggle against the class enemy. The rhet­or­ic of of­fi­cial dis­course had swapped the out­look of war with the enemy within for a glor­i­fy­ing one, closer to what we knew until the last years of the com­mun­ist regime, under Ceau­șes­cu. In the 1960s real­it­ies appear wrapped in a new coat­ing, less shock­ing and more at­tract­ive. The em­phas­is seems to shift from re­pres­sion to per­sua­sion and en­cour­age­ment. The party also tries to dress up its lan­guage: so, in­stead of "per­sua­sion work", a report of 1959, just when this work was being car­ried out most in­tensely in Domașnea, uses the for­mula "com­mis­sion for speed­ing up the pace of the so­cial­ist trans­form­a­tion of ag­ri­cul­ture"(!!).

If we turn to the col­lec­tion of secret doc­u­ments I con­sul­ted, on the one hand, and to the testi­mony of direct par­ti­cipants in col­lect­iv­isa­tion, on the other (I in­ter­viewed 14 people; next to each quo­ta­tion I will give only the number of the in­ter­view), the situ­ation in the com­mune of Domașnea stands in enorm­ous con­trast to the re­as­sur­ing claims of of­fi­cial dis­course.

The files I con­sul­ted show the role the Se­cur­it­ate played in Ro­mania in 1957-1966, how in­form­a­tion cir­cu­lated, what it con­tained, and how the Se­cur­it­ate re­lated to the party. Under cover of the secrecy of the doc­u­ments it pro­duced, it prac­tic­ally never aban­doned the logic of class struggle and of war against in­tern­al en­emies, whom, when it could not always find and identi­fy them, it in­ven­ted, using a "doc­u­ment­a­tion" pro­cess meant to con­firm that each case fitted the identikit of the "hos­tile ele­ment".

If we follow the "in­form­at­ive notes" on "neg­at­ive as­pects" and on "the state of mind" of the mem­bers of the col­lect­ive farm in Domașnea over the period covered by files FD I and FD II, we see them travel up the hier­archy from Com­rade Valeriu Ivan, the op­er­at­ive of­ficer re­spons­ible for local in­form­a­tion, to the dis­trict sec­tion, and from there, through Cap­tain Timir­can (already pro­moted to major by 1965), to the re­gion­al dir­ect­or­ate of the Min­istry of In­tern­al Af­fairs (MAI). Some of the in­form­at­ive notes the dis­trict sec­tion of the MAI sent to the re­gion­al dir­ect­or­ate were also sent "for in­form­a­tion" to the party bodies at the same level, "so that the proper meas­ures could be taken by this route too". At a cer­tain point the Mi­li­tia also became in­volved in the ex­change of in­form­a­tion with the Se­cur­it­ate, send­ing re­ports to it through its rep­res­ent­at­ives at vari­ous levels.

The "state of mind", con­stantly watched, is most often "un­sat­is­fact­ory" or even "agit­ated", and the "neg­at­ive as­pects" con­cern the dis­con­tent or com­ments of the peas­ants or others under watch, some­times quoted (keep­ing some dia­lect fea­tures, pop­u­lar ex­pres­sions or fea­tures of speech), some­times sum­mar­ised.

Com­rade Ivan worked on the spot with a net­work of agents. I tried to talk to one of the people re­cor­ded in the file as part of this net­work, but this person admits to no in­volve­ment and says they do not know who Com­rade Ivan, the op­er­at­ive of­ficer, was, be­cause they were not a party member(!?). Only the post­man re­mem­bers him spon­tan­eously during the in­ter­view and refers to his ac­tions, al­though nearly every­one talks about the Se­cur­it­ate. De­fin­ing it glob­ally, without being able to tie it to spe­cif­ic in­di­vidu­als, is a con­stant in the wit­nesses' ac­counts, which is ul­ti­mately nat­ur­al, given how the in­sti­tu­tion worked.

Some of those in­ter­viewed who did have deal­ings with it de­scribe the ex­per­i­ence. The doc­u­ments in FD II in­clude sev­er­al in­ter­rog­a­tion re­cords and "pledges" which those ques­tioned were forced to write, some­times in their own hand, and to sign. These pledges stated pre­cisely that the per­sons con­cerned would say noth­ing to anyone about their time at the Se­cur­it­ate, ac­cept­ing the legal con­sequences oth­er­wise. They also pledged not to "den­ig­rate" the col­lect­ive farm any more and not to act against it. Mainly, those who ended up under Se­cur­it­ate in­vest­ig­a­tion in 1963, the year these doc­u­ments date from, were those who had wanted to leave the col­lect­ive farm, some­times re­peatedly, or had tried to draw others into doing so. Some of them had been under the Se­cur­it­ate's watch for a long time, as shown by a "nom­in­al table of cer­tain ele­ments who have car­ried out and are car­ry­ing out hos­tile activ­ity against the GAC", a table list­ing 29 people (cf. FD II, f. 178-184). Some of those I in­ter­viewed appear on this list. Some of them were asked, as the pledges show, not only to stop acting against the col­lect­ive farm but also "to carry out per­sua­sion work with those who still try to submit re­quests to leave the col­lect­ive" (FD II, f. 177) or, worse, "to unmask those ele­ments who spread pro­pa­ganda in the vil­lage for leav­ing the GAC and to de­nounce them to the state bodies" (cf. FD II, f. 176).

Among the "hos­tile ele­ments" were "Le­gion­naires, mem­bers of the Na­tion­al Peas­ant Party and the Na­tion­al Lib­er­al Party, as well as other hos­tile ele­ments of other cat­egor­ies, who use the most per­fi­di­ous and cam­ou­flaged meth­ods to hinder the pro­cess of the so­cial­ist trans­form­a­tion of ag­ri­cul­ture" (FD II, f. 63).

Since there was no doubt about the hos­tile char­ac­ter of the ele­ments "slipped into the GAC" or of the sub­vers­ives, given their polit­ic­al past, the re­gion­al Se­cur­it­ate dir­ect­or­ate asked those in the field to present "the prov­ing doc­u­ments" or to gather evid­ence, so that "urgent meas­ures of qual­i­fied in­form­at­ive cov­er­age" could be taken (FD II, f. 58).

In the period before the as­so­ci­ation (întovărășire) or the col­lect­ive farm, the em­phas­is falls on how those tar­geted "in­flu­enced" the in­hab­it­ants of Domașnea not to join the col­lect­ive farm. How did they do this? "Through ru­mours, dis­cred­it­ing the GAC and the as­so­ci­ations, and when these had no effect, through more open ac­tions, such as threats or direct op­pos­i­tion to the meas­ures taken by the Party and the Gov­ern­ment" (FD II, f. 63). As can be seen, in the eyes of the Se­cur­it­ate and from the stand­point of power, speak­ing crit­ic­ally about cer­tain things, threat­en­ing and taking action were all part of the same act of re­bel­lion.

People gath­er­ing in groups of more than 10 could also give rise to the pre­sump­tion that they were to­geth­er there (for ex­ample, in a fellow vil­la­ger­'s house) "to dis­cuss the found­ing of the as­so­ci­ation", or rather "hos­tilely, against its found­ing", a con­clu­sion drawn merely be­cause they had "fallen silent when the party act­iv­ist ap­peared and re­fused to talk to him" (FD II, f. 58).

A report of Feb­ru­ary 1960 states that "in the com­mune of Domașnea and the vil­lage of Cănicea, the wives of some hos­tile ele­ments sought to in­stig­ate (to in­trigue!, the doc­u­ment ac­tu­ally says) cer­tain peas­ants not to join the ag­ri­cul­tur­al as­so­ci­ations" (FD II, f. 91). Ex­amples follow, each stat­ing what the "hos­tile action" con­sisted of. One of the "in­stig­at­ors" had already drawn at­ten­tion before this epis­ode, since, ac­cord­ing to the Se­cur­it­ate's find­ings, she "was sen­tenced to 6 months for not hand­ing over her quotas and for threat­en­ing the local bodies (the People's Coun­cil), and her hus­band was sen­tenced to 4 years for links with the ter­ror­ist bands" (the fu­git­ives in the moun­tains) (FD II, f. 91). This is not the only time women come to the fore.

The Se­cur­it­ate's "doc­u­ment­a­tion"

The oldest data in the file, few in number, date from 1957 and con­cern the situ­ation in the newly foun­ded as­so­ci­ations in the Orșova dis­trict. En­rol­ment was going badly then and later too, and in Domașnea this was put down to "hos­tile ele­ments who had links with the fu­git­ives in the moun­tains". Since this time it con­cerned party mem­bers, sus­pec­ted moreover of having been Le­gion­naires in the past, the Tim­ișoara Re­gion­al Dir­ect­or­ate of the MAI asked the dis­trict Se­cur­it­ate sec­tion (FD I, f. 58), on the one hand, to gather "prov­ing evid­ence" against them and to place them under "in­form­at­ive cov­er­age", and on the other, to inform the dis­trict party com­mit­tee so that they could be ex­pelled.

As noted, the fact that they were "hos­tile ele­ments" had already been es­tab­lished, and the Se­cur­it­ate could re­com­mend their ex­pul­sion from the party, while in­sist­ing on the need to prove the in­crim­in­at­ing facts (it ap­pears that at least one of the people tar­geted by the report had already been through in­ter­rog­a­tions, but these data did not seem suf­fi­cient or con­clus­ive). As order no. 312/12.616 of 31 Janu­ary 1958 shows, "doc­u­ment­a­tion" could also in­clude "identi­fy­ing the per­sons who know about them and who can be ques­tioned, without, how­ever, vi­ol­at­ing pop­u­lar leg­al­ity"(?!).

The pic­ture of "hos­tile ac­tions" grew more varied over time, and the en­emies iden­ti­fied were no longer lim­ited to those from the former polit­ic­al parties or those with links to the "ban­dits" in the moun­tains.

In Cornereva, for ex­ample, the Or­tho­dox priest of the com­mune came under watch, given his in­flu­ence over the com­munity, as did a preach­er of the Lord's Army (report of the dis­trict Se­cur­it­ate sec­tion to the MAI Re­gion­al Dir­ect­or­ate in Tim­ișoara, no. 322 of 23 Janu­ary 1958), who in­ter­preted pas­sages from the Bible "tenden­tiously", in the sense of in­flu­en­cing the vil­la­gers not to join the as­so­ci­ation.

In Domașnea the pres­sure aimed ul­ti­mately at turn­ing the as­so­ci­ation into a col­lect­ive farm. Per­sua­sion, in­tim­id­a­tion and sur­veil­lance went hand in hand. The range of what could be coun­ted as action against the col­lect­ive farm or the as­so­ci­ation was quite wide and un­pre­dict­able.

L.P. (in­ter­view 5), who had 32 first cous­ins, ad­vised them all not to join. He says he car­ried out counter-pro­pa­ganda among his neigh­bours and friends too, and admits that he was threatened by the Se­cur­it­ate with arrest and con­fined to his home until the col­lect­ive was in­aug­ur­ated, es­pe­cially as he was among the few who in the end did not join the col­lect­ive farm. His "hos­tile activ­ity" con­tin­ued after the col­lect­ive farm was foun­ded, and there is a trace in FD II of his passing through a Se­cur­it­ate in­vest­ig­a­tion in 1963. Under in­vest­ig­a­tion he was forced, like the others ques­tioned in the same batch, to sign a pledge that he would not tell anyone he had been ques­tioned. This was prob­ably why he did not men­tion the pledge, al­though it did not in­clude de­noun­cing others, only stop­ping his own pro­pa­ganda against the col­lect­ive farm.

"There was a lot of squeez­ing before they put the halter on our heads, that's how it was," one in­ter­viewee (14) re­marked. She her­self ended up under Se­cur­it­ate in­vest­ig­a­tion be­cause, after the col­lect­ive farm was foun­ded and she had joined under pres­sure, at one point she wanted to leave. Her testi­mony fo­cuses almost en­tirely on her en­counter with the Se­cur­it­ate, and what she stresses most is how she was in­tim­id­ated and hu­mi­li­ated:

"...I kept saying, how can I join the col­lect­ive, how can I work, with two small chil­dren? I had one in the cradle and one a bit bigger, he was five. And I had a hus­band with one arm. And when they came, that's what I told them. They came at night and took me away. (Who?) The Mi­li­tia, the people from the coun­cil. (From here?) Yes, from the coun­cil. And they took me and car­ried me off to Orșova. Be­lieve me if you can, they stripped me like a little child, and they took my papers, the ones from the dead. They talked me over. (Did they beat you too?) No, they didn't beat me, only every two hours they brought me in to ask wheth­er I'd work in the col­lect­ive, then they'd let me go. I told them, I'll work, yes, of course I'll work, only how can I go with these little chil­dren? And I had to put my hus­band's shoes on for him. And then what can I say, they kept at me like that till even­ing, kept taking me away and bring­ing me back. One even­ing they took me again, and I heard the doors open there. God sent them. And when they saw me so shaken, they could only see my blouse and my skirt. And I was hold­ing on to my skirt so it would­n't fall down. They said: 'What about this woman, what crime has she done?' And I burst into tears, but I didn't dare look to see who it was. They stood in front of me and asked: 'What's the matter with you?' I told them I had a hus­band with no arm, from the war, and two small chil­dren. He said: 'Well, write down that she's not fit for work. Don't cry any more!' And straight away they rang and brought me my clothes, and I got dressed. They told me to go to the sta­tion. I said: 'How can I go to the sta­tion when I've no money for the train?' And one of them gave me money for the train and one gave me bread and some soft cheese. I didn't want to take it, but they said: 'How can you go to your chil­dren like this, when they'll ask, Mummy, what have you brought us?!' And I went to the sta­tion, and there were a lot of people there, and sud­denly I felt someone take me by the shoulder like this, and I saw it was one of them, and they bought me a ticket and I came home. (Who were they? Do you know them?) No, I don't know them, but they were well-dressed people, decent people, edu­cated people. (...) (Were you afraid?) Well, how could you not be afraid? (And the ones who took you away, were they from the vil­lage?) Yes, from the vil­lage, but he croaked; the bad ill­ness took him and he died, he died with his wife, and the child sold the house and he's a wreck. God didn't spare them."

I no­ticed that two themes often appear in ac­counts of this kind: the ap­pear­ance of a sa­viour, a piece of sta­ging the Se­cur­it­ate used, as prison testi­mon­ies show, to con­fuse the person being ques­tioned; and the belief that things are set right again by divine pun­ish­ment of the one who did wrong.

In Domașnea the as­so­ci­ation was not dis­solved in 1962, as it was in all the sur­round­ing vil­lages and com­munes. The wit­nesses tend to at­trib­ute this to the zeal of some local of­fi­cials, one of whom is most often de­mon­ised. This is the act­iv­ist Toma, deputy sec­ret­ary of the dis­trict, of whom someone re­counts that in the morn­ing, between 7.30 and 8, ex­actly when the chil­dren had to go to school, he would shoot at buck­ets filled with water, for prac­tice but cer­tainly also to in­tim­id­ate. Mean­while, those living in the same yard were con­fined to the house until the morn­ing ex­er­cise was over.

For others his pres­ence in the vil­lage had direct con­sequences. Here is what someone re­mem­bers (in­ter­view 8):

"We didn't want to join the as­so­ci­ation, be­cause I also had two little sis­ters and I could­n't sign up for them, be­cause our father had died. (You held the land to­geth­er?) Yes, I held the land to­geth­er with them. And then they kept coming and per­se­cut­ing us. And then my hus­band went to the ma­chine and tract­or sta­tion in Caranse­beș, be­cause he worked at Zăgujeni; he didn't come home for two months, and I stayed here and they ar­res­ted me... Com­rade Toma. (Was he a party act­iv­ist?) Yes, the party act­iv­ist. (And what year did they arrest you?) In '58. He ar­res­ted me and kept me 48 hours without food or sleep and put me here in the People's Coun­cil, where the shops are now, to chop wood be­cause I would­n't join the as­so­ci­ation. Then my eldest child came and cried at the door with my mother and said, 'Come on, Mummy, sign up!' They cursed us too, they swore at us too, they beat us too. (Was it just him, or were there more?) There was the Mi­li­tia too, and an­oth­er party act­iv­ist, but I didn't know him. But Toma I knew... he per­se­cuted us the most. And then from the com­mune there was one Flo­r­ica Oroane. And then there was Ion Răduța, who also per­se­cuted us to the bone. (What did he do?) He'd make us go with the cart for com­puls­ory labour at night; he'd get us up at two to go to the sta­tion and fetch flour, be­cause he had shops at the co­oper­at­ives. At night, through the snow, he'd make us go with the cart to haul flour."

These are not the only troubles the col­lect­ive brought into their lives, nor the only abuses they suffered:

"We handed over carts with two horses, a harrow, a plough, a maize plant­er. I came home with just the halter and the whip, and on my word I came home crying, be­cause I gave up young horses, a three-year-old mare and a five-year-old horse; I handed them over at the Coun­cil. A year later they took them and brought them here and sold them round the vil­lages, in Rusca, at Oraca, and they took the money."

Toma's abuses are also men­tioned in a Se­cur­it­ate report of 1965, which says he had food brought by car from Her­cu­lane for him­self and for those with whom he quite often went on binges.

"He (Toma, ed­it­or­'s note) sat at headquar­ters and spread us out, and in the even­ing, the review. Each of us had a number of houses, a sector. (How many of these com­mis­sions were there?) Oh, I think there were about 20. (And how many in a com­mis­sion?) Four or five. To in­struct people that the col­lect­ive farm is good. They even gave us les­sons. They'd bring an ag­ro­nom­ist who'd show us on the black­board that it pro­duces so much wheat, but they were as­tro­nom­ic­al fig­ures; we, who knew the facts, knew, but what could you do? (You real­ised it wasn't so?) Well, we real­ised, but what could you do... (Did you know others who already had a col­lect­ive farm?) We knew, be­cause we had con­nec­tions in Tim­ișoara, in Ol­tenia; we knew how people lived on the col­lect­ive farm, plus those who'd been at the front in Russia knew what a kolk­hoz means. One of them, Petru Românu, ran off and became a par­tis­an be­cause of it, and he said it wasn't good. Plus there were many old people who told what a kolk­hoz means. (...)

And they di­vided us into sec­tors. They came to every­one, and the ver­dict was: 'Either you join the col­lect­ive or we throw your child out of uni­versity' (...) An­oth­er method was through jobs. They'd send people home and tell them: 'I won't take you back at work until you bring a cer­ti­fic­ate that you've joined the col­lect­ive farm.' An­oth­er method, since many had been con­victed polit­ic­ally and had done prison, was to tell them: 'What do you want, are you set­ting your­self against the state? Do you want me to put you in prison again?' The Se­cur­it­ate was here; many res­isted, and they'd come in the even­ing by car, take them all the way to Orșova and hold them for a day, and in the even­ing send them back. I don't know wheth­er they beat them or not, but they took them for a ride." (in­ter­view 9)

Those who got to the apple pot

Gradu­ally, the divide between "them" (the power) and "us" (the vic­tims) ap­peared within the com­munity itself. Those who "got to the apple pot", as some put it, were seen by the others as a kind of cor­rupt and cyn­ic­al gang.

Here is how a peas­ant, a war vet­er­an who also drew the at­ten­tion of the Se­cur­it­ate, de­scribes the events of those years (in­ter­view 6):

"Col­lect­iv­isa­tion began by force. A gang of people formed it, wheth­er they got some­thing from the state, from the state lead­er­ship, or were forced. With some people they found all sorts of reas­ons: you did this, you did that. So people, what could they do, joined the col­lect­ive. But some 40 fam­il­ies didn't join.

And they made fools of these people: you worked a sum­mer­'s day for noth­ing, be­cause they didn't give you a single coin per work­day. Not even a 5-bani coin did they give you. You went out to the field with your bag of food and came home with noth­ing, be­cause the Mi­li­tia was there. (...) They made fools of us, as if we were nobody's tool... that's what com­mun­ism was like. It's no use some saying it was good; those who say so are the ones who lived well, be­cause under the com­mun­ists it was good nowhere. But we know what it was like...

(Who lived well?) Well, their gang. They would­n't even let you have the pas­ture, and they'd see to it that we were given bad land, good for noth­ing1, to wear you down some­how, so that in the end you'd give in, so you'd see there was no point any more. All day, morn­ing and even­ing, we'd wake up with them in the room. (Did they come to you too?) Yes, 3 or 4 of them would come into the room and would­n't leave. They'd tell us, 'Just sign,' and I'd tell him, 'I can't sign.' 'What do you mean you can't? You won't, be­cause you're against the party, against us.'" (in­ter­view 6)

For some of those in­ter­viewed, the change the col­lect­ive brought lay pre­cisely in the di­vi­sion of the com­munity, which also ex­plains why the col­lect­ive was good for some and not for others:

"(Do you think the col­lect­ive changed the way people were?) Of course it did. (In what way?) Well, some were more pro­tec­ted, others wer­en't. (And were there con­flicts?) No, there were no con­flicts, but we could see who was more pro­tec­ted. Be­cause those who stole by the cart­load were pro­tec­ted. You don't go and steal a cart­load of apples or a cart­load of maize or plums at night. Of course you had an un­der­stand­ing with the police, with the team leader, with the pres­id­ent of the col­lect­ive. (So that's how it worked, with un­der­stand­ings like that?) Yes, of course, be­cause he didn't steal only for him­self, he stole for them too; they shared it. (Did they share among them­selves, or give to the bigger bosses too?) The big ones came and took rachie by the car­load." (in­ter­view 10)

"That's what they said: 'Who stole with the motor, the dis­trict for­gave; who stole with the sack, the devil took, and he did prison.' (Who made up these verses?) People in the vil­lage said them. Some worked and others took. That's how it was. And what they gave a person was noth­ing at all. Three people built them­selves houses in Domașnea with my cart; they worked on the house, and then they took it and sold it. Woe and bit­ter­ness!" (in­ter­view 8). Con­flicts and para­dox­ic­al situ­ations of this kind also af­fected family life. Cases where one family member joined the com­mun­ists, des­pite the per­se­cu­tion they in­flic­ted on an­oth­er member of the family, or per­haps pre­cisely in the hope of saving some­thing, were not rare.

An­oth­er in­ter­viewee (in­ter­view 2) shows that, al­though his ma­ter­nal grand­fath­er, a man of prop­erty, had set out pre­cisely to de­vel­op the estate, he was forced to admit in the 1950s that he was out of step with the times. The ex­cess­ive quotas, the "sta­bil­isa­tion" and being classed as a kulak gradu­ally made it im­possible for him to keep his land. Al­though he was "the main pawn in the family", as he puts it him­self, the future team leader was forced to take a job to have money to pay the taxes. The family man­aged to split the land into three parts, so that in­stead of being re­gistered with 15 ha, each gen­er­a­tion ap­peared with only 5; the three fam­il­ies then also lived apart. The heavy pres­sure made every member of the family join the col­lect­ive, and the grand­son became a team leader. The ma­ter­nal grand­fath­er, who died shortly af­ter­wards, summed up a situ­ation which, even if he un­der­stood it, he could not accept easily or without regret: "Eh, son, they've bought you, these people have!"

The res­ist­ance

On the other side, the Se­cur­it­ate car­ried on, in the style already shown, its sur­veil­lance aimed at un­cov­er­ing "hos­tile activ­ity" and "the short­com­ings shown in the so­cial­ist trans­form­a­tion of ag­ri­cul­ture". The over­all pic­ture of these years shows how wide­spread the re­fus­al to accept col­lect­iv­isa­tion was, and the grow­ing worry of the au­thor­it­ies, whose sur­veil­lance and "in­form­at­ive pro­cessing" in­tens­i­fied. The number of agents in the coun­tryside in the dis­trict had risen to 47, of whom 40 agents were "handed over to the res­id­ency"(!?).

This was the at­mo­sphere in which the Domașnea col­lect­ive farm was cre­ated on 8 April 1962.

Among the ways of re­fus­ing or post­pon­ing en­rol­ment, people claimed that the prop­erty be­longed to par­ents, in-laws or a family member who was tem­por­ar­ily away from home. In Cănicea people fled into the forest when the per­sua­sion com­mis­sions came. But the winter of 1961-1962, the testi­mon­ies say, was a hard one, and flee­ing to the forest was no longer pos­sible. A number of "ele­ments", to use the Se­cur­it­ate's ex­pres­sion, who had not joined the as­so­ci­ation joined the col­lect­ive farm dir­ectly. They were also the first to give trouble both to the local au­thor­it­ies and to the Se­cur­it­ate, be­cause, having sown their land before join­ing the col­lect­ive farm, they asked to har­vest their wheat in­di­vidu­ally.

Having been re­fused by the col­lect­ive farm's man­age­ment coun­cil, they wrote higher up, dir­ectly to the Su­preme Coun­cil of Ag­ri­cul­ture, which replied that they would re­ceive ap­prov­al from the re­gion­al Coun­cil. So 14 people went to Tim­ișoara and won their case.

The re­gion­al Se­cur­it­ate de­man­ded re­ports on "the state of mind" every 10 days (order cab. 736 of Decem­ber 1959 and no. 320/11.532 of 13 July 1961). The fear was that the dis­con­tent might spread "without the causes of this dis­con­tent being known, or who stands at its head" (FD I, f. 335).

A first series of re­quests to leave the col­lect­ive, ad­dressed to the Su­preme Coun­cil of Ag­ri­cul­ture, was re­por­ted around 20 Oc­to­ber 1962, a few months after the col­lect­ive farm was foun­ded, and it set off a wide-ran­ging "in­form­at­ive pro­cessing". The Se­cur­it­ate wanted to know how the col­lect­ive farm­er­s' action star­ted, how the ap­plic­a­tion form was ob­tained and who filled it in, and who the ini­ti­at­ors were (cf. report no. 128.403 of 29 Oc­to­ber 1962), and it learned through its agents that the peas­ants, warned that their let­ters would be held back at the post office (I saw one such in­ter­cep­ted letter in the file, and we also have the testi­mony of the post­man of that time), were trying to send their let­ters from neigh­bour­ing com­munes. Ac­cord­ing to the in­form­at­ive notes, over 100 people wanted to leave, some making state­ments hos­tile not only to the col­lect­ive farm but also to the party, which they called a thief, and fore­see­ing its fall from power, since people had grown poor and the state took everything from them. The col­lect­ive farm­ers also dis­cussed the in­ter­na­tion­al situ­ation and re­ferred to the 1956 re­volu­tion in Hun­gary. In this es­pe­cially agit­ated con­text, the Se­cur­it­ate went to Domașnea and talked to those in­volved, noting the stub­born­ness and de­term­in­a­tion of some, who were later watched and ques­tioned. FD II, f. 227-231 holds two in­ter­rog­a­tion re­cords from the in­vest­ig­a­tions car­ried out on 26-30 Oc­to­ber 1962.

Des­pite the re­pres­sion, a group of 17 people "went to Bucharest to com­plain about their re­quests to leave the col­lect­ive farm and about having been ques­tioned by the Se­cur­it­ate" (tele­phone note, bul­let­in no. 128752 of 20 Novem­ber 1962).

The high point of the events that fol­lowed forced col­lect­iv­isa­tion, re­cor­ded in tele­phone note bul­let­in no. 128752 of 20 Novem­ber 1962, was the revolt on the even­ing of 19 Novem­ber 1962, which re­mained in the memory of many people of Domașnea (in­ter­views 2, 10, 14). In Bucharest the pe­ti­tion­ers had been prom­ised that a rep­res­ent­at­ive of the Min­istry of Ag­ri­cul­ture would be sent to the vil­lage and a gen­er­al meet­ing held so they could state their griev­ances. On the even­ing of 19 Novem­ber 1962 the women spread the word to each other that the meet­ing would be held in front of the Coun­cil, and they gathered there in quite large num­bers. Many men were there too, some hoping a del­eg­ate from Bucharest would arrive by car so they could talk to him. As the Se­cur­it­ate agent re­ports, there was a clear in­ten­tion to push the women to the front. The head of the mi­li­tia post with­drew into the Coun­cil build­ing and drew the shut­ters, as the women shouted at him to leave the build­ing open.

An­oth­er tele­phone note of 20 Novem­ber 1962, 4 a.m. (FD II, f. 213-214), speaks of sev­er­al groups of people who gathered near the People's Coun­cil, "shout­ing against the col­lect­ive farm of Domașnea". On the report of the mi­li­tia post, the Se­cur­it­ate, ac­com­pan­ied by party and Mi­li­tia of­fi­cials, went to the scene "ad­vising people to go home, as their at­ti­tude was con­trary to the laws of the state". The people did not seem much in­tim­id­ated.

In the in­vest­ig­a­tions that fol­lowed, one of the women ques­tioned gave the number of 2,000 people present at the meet­ing (a figure that seems ex­ag­ger­ated; it was prob­ably 200-300, as some of those I in­ter­viewed say) and, under in­ter­rog­a­tion, named whom she had stood next to at the meet­ing. The Se­cur­it­ate's notes con­firm the scale the in­vest­ig­a­tion took and reveal its harsh pro­ced­ures, but also fur­ther de­tails about the meet­ing. Some were said to have stirred up the women, others to have shouted: "Stay here, don't leave!" A woman, So­lo­mia lui Purec, fell down after pulling at the door.

The Se­cur­it­ate rarely men­tions the prac­tic­al con­sequences of its re­ports. In many cases, such as that of Sofia Românu, who, thanks also to the stand­ing she had in the vil­lage as a keener (a pro­fes­sion­al mourn­er), came to the fore in the revolt of Novem­ber 1962, arrest fol­lowed.

In any case, in 1963 the situ­ation re­mained tense, and people began to real­ise that those in Bucharest backed the col­lect­ive farm's man­age­ment (cf. note 125.033 of 8 Janu­ary 1963). In 1964 turnout for work was poor, animal mor­tal­ity was high again, or­gan­isa­tion was bad and pro­ductiv­ity low. In May 1965, 54 col­lect­ive farm­ers sub­mit­ted re­quests to leave.

The report of 12 May 1965 (FD I, f. 140) by Timir­can, pro­moted in the mean­time from cap­tain to major, gives one pause. It is a kind of sum­mary report and seems to sug­gest that the act­iv­ist Toma and his boss at the dis­trict party com­mit­tee, the dis­trict first sec­ret­ary Dănilă Pușcaș (re­placed in the mean­time), were not only solely re­spons­ible for the abuses and re­pres­sion that dom­in­ated col­lect­iv­isa­tion in Domașnea, but had also ini­ti­ated them.

De­noun­cing the party lead­er­ship as the only cul­prit, des­pite the evid­ence, shows that after the death of Ghe­orghiu-Dej (in March 1965), prob­ably older ten­sions between the two levers of power came to light, and that the role of judge of the facts, the last­ing ar­bit­er of com­mun­ist power, would still be the Se­cur­it­ate, which even after 1989 would plead its hon­our­ab­il­ity and its wholly pat­ri­ot­ic char­ac­ter.

(The re­search behind this art­icle was car­ried out within the pro­ject "The Col­lect­iv­isa­tion of Ro­mania, 1949-1964", led by Gail Klig­man and Kath­er­ine Ver­dery.)

1. This refers to the con­sol­id­a­tion of land, through which peas­ants who had not joined the col­lect­ive lost the good land near the vil­lage and re­ceived bad land in ex­change, far from the vil­lage (cf. also in­ter­view 4).

Who steals with the sack, the devil takes him
Who steals with the scythe, the farm for­gives him
Who steals by the lorry
The dis­trict for­gives him

(at­trib­uted to Sofia Românu, known as Mar­cioane).